Yankees Face Uncertain Third Base Future with McMahon and Caballero Likely to Platoon in 2027
The Yankees continue to seek a reliable third baseman, with internal options Ryan McMahon and Jose Caballero expected to share duties if no external acquisition is made.
According to sports.yahoo.com, The New York Yankees have struggled to find a consistent third baseman since acquiring Jazz Chisholm Jr. in 2024, leading to multiple attempts to fill the position with players like Ryan McMahon, Amed Rosario, and Jose Caballero.
Ryan McMahon, despite above-average defense, has underperformed offensively, contributing to a weak spot in the Yankees' lineup. Amed Rosario, now a free agent, served primarily as a bench player with occasional starts.
Jose Caballero has been used as a bench piece and occasional starter but has not established himself as an everyday player. Without adding an external candidate, the Yankees are likely to rely on a platoon between McMahon and Caballero to cover third base in 2027.